Old Town Trolley is officially open again!

logo-print
Skip to content

Key West Restaurant Guide

  • Dining Dining
  • Restrooms Restrooms

Smokin’ Tuna Saloon

Nearest Trolley Stop: #3
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minute walk
4 Charles Street
(305) 517-6350
Best live music in Key West. Delicious seafood on a secluded Old Town street.

Two Friends Patio

Nearest Trolley Stop: #3
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minute walk
512 Front Street
(305) 296-3121
A Key West icon since 1967; serving fresh seafood, fabulous drinks and Karaoke all in an open air patio.

Blue Macaw

Nearest Trolley Stop: #5
Distance to Trolley Stop: At the stop
804 Whitehead Street
Featuring fresh local seafood, build your own Bloody Mary bar and live music.

Glazed Donuts

Nearest Trolley Stop: #4
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minute walk
420 Eaton Street
(305) 296-9142
The Southernmost Donut Shop in the USA; featuring homemade, gourmet donuts.

Hog’s Breath Saloon

Nearest Trolley Stop: #1
Distance to Trolley Stop: 3 Minute Walk
400 Front Street
(305) 296-4222
Hog’s Breath is better than no breath at all! Good times, great entertainment and fun, not to mention the drinks and food are outstanding!

Lagerhead Beach Bar and Water Sports

Nearest Trolley Stop: #3
Distance to Trolley Stop: 2 minute walk
0 Simonton Street
(305) 293-2033
Great seafood, burgers and drinks on the beach overlooking the Key West Harbor.

Fisherman’s Cafe

Nearest Trolley Stop: #2
Distance to Trolley Stop: 2 Blocks
205 Elizabeth Street
(305) 900-6878
Best Cuban Coffee on the island. Local’s hidden gem serving breakfast sandwiches, Florida lobster tacos, and quick bites for the traveler on the go.

Cuban Coffee Queen

Nearest Trolley Stop: #2
Distance to Trolley Stop: At the stop!
284 Margaret St.
(305) 294-7787
Enjoy breakfast and lunch at this secret Key West Restaurant. Cuban Coffee Queen is an authentic, local Key West Café with delicious coffee and sandwiches.

Pinchers Crab Shack

Nearest Trolley Stop: #13
Distance to Trolley Stop: 2 minutes
712 Duval Street
(305) 440-2179
Amazing local seafood in a fun atmosphere overlooking Duval Street.

Irish Kevin’s

Nearest Trolley Stop: #3
Distance to Trolley Stop: Five minute walk
211 Duval Street
(305) 292-1262
With over 20 beers on tap, delicious food and live entertainment, it’s the place visitors and locals alike go for a good time.

Kelly’s Caribbean Bar & Grill

Nearest Trolley Stop: #1
Distance to Trolley Stop: 10 minute walk
301 Whitehead Street
(305) 293-8484
Actress Kelly McGillis’ Caribbean Bar & Grill is home to fine island cuisine and the Southernmost Brewery in the USA!

El Meson de Pepe

Nearest Trolley Stop: #1
Distance to Trolley Stop: 2 minute walk
410 Wall Street
(305) 295-2620
A family-owned and operated Cuban restaurant dedicated to great quality food and the preservation of Cuban-Conch Heritage in Key West.

Haagen-Dazs

America’s favorite ice cream in all the wonderful flavors.
425 Front Street
(305) 296-2299

Mangia Mangia

Nearest Trolley Stop: #2 & #4
Distance to Trolley Stop(s): Beautiful 15 minute stroll through Old Town Key West
900 Southard Street
(305) 294-2469
Fresh pasta at its finest. Open every day at 5:30 PM, seating until 10:00 PM.

Hard Rock Café

Nearest Trolley Stops: #3 & #4
Distance to Trolley Stop(s): Great 10 minute stroll down Duval Street
313 Duval Street
(305) 293-0230
Typical American food, as well as rock-music memorabilia and plenty of Hard Rock-branded merchandise.

Pat Croce’s Rum Barrel

Nearest Trolley Stop: #3
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minute walk
528 Front Street
(305) 292-7862
The best selection of rum in the world, signature dishes like Smoked Turkey Legs and Barrels of Buffalo Chicken Tenders, a rooftop deck overlooking Old Town and live music nightly.

The Café

Nearest Trolley Stop: #4
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minute walk
509 Southard
(305) 293-0230
A mostly vegetarian place. Delicious vegetarian & vegan dining.

Salute!

Nearest Trolley Stop: #10
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minute walk
1000 Atlantic Ave
(305) 292-1117
Delicious Italian dining right on the beach.

Santiago’s Bodega

Nearest Trolley Stop: #5
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minute walk
207 Petronia St
(305) 296-7691
Tapas-style dining with a fabulous wine list in the heart of Bahama Village.

Fogarty’s

Nearest Trolley Stop: #3
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minutes
227 Duval Street
(305) 294-7525
Located in one of the most historic areas with great food at downright reasonable prices and home to the Flying Monkey Bar, an outdoor, mostly mellow bar.

Mattheessen’s

106 Duval Street
Key West, FL 33040
Nearest Trolley Stop: #1
Distance to Trolley Stop: 8 Minute Walk
(305) 296-1616
Delicious cookies, ice cream and fudge.

300 Front Street
Key West, FL 33040
Nearest Trolley Stop: #1
Distance to Trolley Stop: 3 Minute Walk
(305) 396-7453
Delicious cookies, ice cream and fudge.

419d Duval Street
Key West, FL 33040
(305) 296-8014
Delicious cookies and fudge.

Bien

Nearest Trolley Stop: #2
Distance to Trolley Stop: 10 Minute Walk
1000 Eaton St.
(305) 517-6740
Delicious Caribbean influenced sandwiches and rice bowls. The best black beans ever!

Half Shell Raw Bar

Nearest Trolley Stop: #2
Distance to Trolley Stop: 1 Minute Walk
231 Margaret St.
(305) 294-7496
A Key West classic. Waterfront dining with a large menu of local seafood and fresh oysters, clams and shrimp served your way.

Turtle Kraals

Nearest Trolley Stop: #2
Distance to Trolley Stop: 1 Minute Walk
231 Margaret St.
(305) 294-2640
A Key West icon, enjoy delicious seafood, burgers and bar-b-que located in the historic turtle kraals on the Key West Waterfront. One of the largest beer selections on the island.

Charlie Mac’s

Nearest Trolley Stop: #13
Distance to Trolley Stop: 8 Minute Walk
404 Southard St.
(305) 320-0204
The island’s best bar-b-que inspired by the sizzling pits of South Carolina. Live music, large selection of beers and spirits.

Island Dogs

Nearest Trolley Stop: #13
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 Minute Walk
505 Front St.
(305) 509-7136
Come as you are! One of Key West’s favorite watering holes features an impressive menu of exotic hot dogs, authentic Boston pub pizza, and top notch bar favorites specially created by Iron Chef protégé Patrick Dunn.

Amigos Taco Bar

Nearest Trolley Stop: #1
425 Greene Street
(305) 292-2009
Fresh and healthy tacos, burritos, nachos, quesadillas and more!

Red Fish Blue Fish

Nearest Trolley Stop: #1
Distance to Trolley Stop: 2 minute walk
407 Front Street
(305) 295-7447
Delicious seafood in the heart of Mallory Square.

Caroline’s Café

Nearest Trolley Stop: #4
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minutes
310 Duval Street
(305) 294-7511
Salads, sandwiches, seafood and such. Plus the biggest burger on the island!

Mangoes

Nearest Trolley Stop: #13
Distance to Trolley Stop: 1 minute
509 Duval Street
(305) 292-4606
A delicious selection of Floribbean and American foods.

Jack Flats

Nearest Trolley Stop: #4
Distance to Trolley Stop: 5 minutes
509 Duval Street
(305) 294-7955
Key West’s only sports bar with 12 projection screens, 11 plasma tv’s, EVERY Sports package & amazing homemade food. 12 oz burgers, ginormous Grouper sandwiches, delicious app’s & great drink prices!!!

Denny’s Old Town

Nearest Trolley Stop: #12
Distance to Trolley Stop: 1 minute
925 Duval Street
(305) 294-5065
Round-the-clock breakfast and casual family dining across America.

Up Up
Back to top